There is a lot of bad news in the poll of afghan public opinion released yesterday by abc news, the bbc, and ard. Princeton politics professor kosuke imai and colleagues have found that the hearts and minds strategy used by international forces in iraq and afghanistan to win over civilians can make those same civilians more likely to be attacked by insurgents. By 1987 and 1988, however, soviet thinking and practice had evolved. Winning hearts and minds in afghanistan carries risks. The reason behind the rather lighthearted title of the book will become. Bush administration, whose neoconservatism and hubris rather than careful analysis of genuine threats, national interests, and reasonable options shaped its policies. Defections to the taliban and now also the isil affiliates are rising rapidly amongst the socalled afghan national army. In past conflicts, notably during the vietnam war, the u. History afghan foreign relations civilian casualties psychological aspects humanitarian aid military maneuvers analysis military operations russian foreign relations soldiers beliefs, opinions and attitudes. Hammes wrote that counterinsurgency is not a strategy any more than antiaircraft is a strategy. Americas goals in afghanistan were lofty to begin with. Edited by historian and marine lieutenant colonel aaron b. Hearts and minds is how repression had to be dressed up for consumption back in britain post1945.
Nonetheless, the prevailing view among western historians that the soviets did not attempt any kind of heartsandminds strategy in afghanistan is clearly wrong. Even if soviet heartsandminds operations did not win the soviet union many friends, they did take place, and did provide some benefits to those who received them. Is losing hearts and minds in afghanistan nprs steve inskeep speaks with aaron oconnell about his book our latest longest war. If iraq was unpopular, afghanistan was misunderstood, and it was vital to get a clear explanation of what we were doing and why. The hearts and minds strategy, then, was a constantly evolving. Such a book will address the thorny question of the extent that iran and russia assisted the taliban, the widespread corruption of american and nato troops in their drug and weapons dealings with the afghan people and the taliban, the role of the cia also barely mentioned in promoting the heroin trade, the use of prescription opiates given to. Our latest longest war is a book which discusses minute issues which led us to loose the afghan war despite spending rather waisting trillion of. Pentagon budgets are soaring even as wars in places like afghanistan continue to go poorly. Jun 01, 2018 one way to sense the emergence of a standard interpretation is when the literature unfolds with a wide range of observers drawing similar conclusions. In the afghanistan war for hearts and minds, too much money, given too fast may actually lose the battle for usaid. Our latest longest war is a chronicle of how, why, and in what ways the war in afghanistan failed. Find out more at through afghanistans modern history, culture. Some officers are accused of selling weapons to the taliban. More than fifteen years and three quarters of a trillion dollars after the us invasion of afghanistan, its clear.
Jul 28, 2010 in the afghanistan war for hearts and minds, usaid lost its battle in badakshan province. Jul 31, 2009 new taliban rule book aims to win afghan hearts and minds. Dec 01, 2005 last month afj took a look inside provincial reconstruction teams in afghanistan, and vance serchuk pronounced these joint civilianmilitary efforts to be a key to winning the hearts and minds of afghans, buttressing the authority of the government in kabul and providing a central effort in the u. Mckiernan raises effort to win afghan hearts and minds to a. Losing hearts and minds in afghanistan as want to read. The common term for such a strategy is populationcentric. Winning hearts and minds in afghanistan the glidd of. The myth of hearts and mindsby vegetiusdownload the full article.
The classic british counterinsurgency approach is open to widely divergent interpretations. The conflict will be won, general stanley mcchrystal, the top. Hearts and minds is bad strategy a hearts and minds approach is predicated on the proposition that we foreign, western, culturally christian, invaders can persuade a sizeable proportion of the pashtun population to cut themselves off from their cultural roots. Dec 23, 2015 some officers are accused of selling weapons to the taliban. Instead, they simply did their best to depopulate the countryside by attack ing civilians in the villages in which they lived. Perennial problems such as washingtons predilection for making decisions but not following up on implementation, peripatetic approach to funding the strategy. Pacification is the more formal term for winning hearts and minds. Our latest longest war is a book which discusses minute issues which led us to loose the afghan war despite spending rather waisting trillion of tax payers money. In other words, winning hearts and minds may be the effectrather than causeof victory. Beyond hearts and minds a dissertation submitted to the faculty of the graduate school of arts and sciences of georgetown university in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of doctor of philosophy in government by raphael s. Heartsandminds is bad strategy a heartsandminds approach is predicated on the proposition that we foreign, western, culturally christian, invaders can persuade a sizeable proportion of the pashtun population to cut themselves off from their cultural roots. Use features like bookmarks, note taking and highlighting while reading the wrong war. Indeed, this strategy of divide and rule is the essence of british colonial policy rather than any spurious notion of winning over hearts and minds.
The term hearts and minds has been misunderstood since gen templer used it in 1952 a term which he regretted using see the book hearts and minds in guerrilla warfare. How to win hearts and minds in afghanistan pov regarding. Grit, strategy, and the way out of afghanistan kindle edition by west, bing. Hearts and minds was a public relations campaign used in the iraq war. The array of expert voices assembled amplifies the message across nearly every aspect of afghan war strategy and policy. Oconnell is published by university of chicago press. The idea of winning the hearts and minds of the population carries the connotation that there is somehow a magic formula that will turn the population. Time to move on from hearts and minds small wars journal. Afghan views on wham a key strategy of the coalition forces war against the taliban. Bush administration, whose neoconservatism and hubris rather than careful analysis of genuine threats, national interests, and reasonable options shaped its. The ultimate goal of this hearts and minds strategy was to create allies among the. Hearts and minds is a wonderful name for a teen romance novel, but ive always thought it to be a poor name for a counterinsurgency concept. A girl fills a water jug in the village of kor kah, where locals voted to use. Download it once and read it on your kindle device, pc, phones or tablets.
Mckiernan raises effort to win afghan hearts and minds to. His officers say that you cannot gain the trust of the afghan population if you only talk to half of it. In its contemporary version, the united states has embraced an elaborate and financially costly strategy known as winning hearts and minds wham among the populations of iraq and afghanistan. Jul 28, 2010 in the afghanistan war for hearts and minds, too much money, given too fast may actually lose the battle for usaid. The myth of hearts and mindshearts and minds is a wonderful name for a teen romance novel, but ive always thought it to be a poor name for a counterinsurgency concept. Counterinsurgency and reconstruction programs in vietnam. These sailors in arms lived amongst the afghans, and in doing so bring the untold, inside story of the hearts and minds of the afghan air corps. Oconnell, the essays collected here represent nine different perspectives on the warall from veterans of the conflict, both american and afghan. He said that in the future, afghan forces will enter villagers.
Her job while in the country from 2010 to 2011 was to develop relations with afghan villagers, particularly women, so that military leaders would better understand the local culture. In the afghanistan war for hearts and minds, usaid lost its battle in badakshan province. It goes by the unpropitious name of wham winning hearts and minds and its a key strategy in the coalition forces war against the taliban and other insurgents. The thin, blue paperback booklet could be a key weapon in the movements efforts to counter western efforts to win the hearts and minds of the afghan people. The vast expense of these two contemporary wham campaigns casts doubt on. They were a distinct afterthought to other military operations rather than an integrated part of an overall strategy to win the support of the afghan population. Of course we need to win the hearts and minds of the people of helmand, but we also need to win, or retain, the hearts and minds of the people in this country. In my latest article for, i argue the pentagon has won the war that matters. The american struggle for vietnams hearts and minds, a necessary book on americas pacification efforts there. The vast expense of these two contemporary wham campaigns casts doubt on the strategys use in other violent theaters. July 31 mullah mohammad omar, the reclusive leader of afghanistans taliban, has. Mckiernan raises effort to win afghan hearts and minds to a new level 05122009 05. Dec 01, 2009 briefing book money cant buy america love. The pocketsized rule book for the mujahedin of the islamic emirate of afghanistan is a.
Alumna helps military build afghanus relations news. Losing hearts and minds in afghanistan edited by aaron b. Hearts and minds vietnam or winning hearts and minds refers to the strategy and programs used by the governments of vietnam and the united states during the vietnam war to win the popular support of the vietnamese people and to help defeat the viet cong insurgency. This has become the case with the afghan war, with an increasingly tall stack of weighty volumes decrying the failure of u. Afghanistans contested culture was a lecture by jolyon leslie on the 11th of march 2020. Oconnells recent interview with npr cites the vietnam example as he explains the one step forward, two steps back, nature of americas afghan war. Testing whether successfully winning hearts and minds is the cause or the effect of victory proves tricky. Hearts, minds, and hydras outlines the reasons for these worsening situations. As king so aptly explains, the phrase three cups of.
The teams, which are to meet with the afghan women in their homes, assess their need for aid and gather intelligence, are part of gen. This reverence extends to the book that they believe to be. More than fifteen years and three quarters of a trillion dollars after the us invasion of afghanistan, its clear that the united states followed neither rule well. The books rise in influence coincided with a growing belief that the war effort was faltering, in part because. New taliban rule book aims for afghan hearts and minds. The most crucial were selfdefeating decisions made by the george w. It is often seen as a populationcentric attempt to win the hearts and minds of the local population and defined against the more violent, enemycentric conventional warfare approach. Mckiernan raises effort to win afghan hearts and minds to a new level. Losing hearts and minds in afghanistan oconnell, aaron b. Nov 02, 2008 afghan views on wham a key strategy of the coalition forces war against the taliban. David mckiernan, is ratcheting up his efforts to counter the burgeoning insurgency. This has spurred distrust and resentment amongst the very populations whose hearts and minds they so desperately sought to win, pushing them into the waiting hands of the taliban. New taliban rule book aims to win afghan hearts and minds.
The vietnam war, of course, a lesson not lost on aaron oconnell, a u. The essays collectively consider a diverse set of issues, including the influence of washington policy, strategy, training afghan. War for hearts and minds cannot be waged alongside reckless violence and utter disrespect for faith. Soviet heartsandminds operations in afghanistan by. Losing hearts and minds in afghanistan, edited by aaron b. Mckiernan told the afghans that president barack obamas new strategy is to combat instability in the pakistanafghanistan region as a whole. Last month afj took a look inside provincial reconstruction teams in afghanistan, and vance serchuk pronounced these joint civilianmilitary efforts to be a key to winning the hearts and minds of afghans, buttressing the authority of the government in kabul and providing a central effort in the u. And thus, he is singularly suited to chair the panel. So now tell me how their current strategy is a winning one. The strategy of winning hearts and minds once trumpeted by the foreign forces has ended up in the tormenting of hearts and minds of the afghans.
As king so aptly explains, the phrase three cups of tea has been. Soviet hearts and minds 3 the means of survival, would be forced to move away. Aug 26, 2010 how to win hearts and minds in afghanistan. Losing hearts and minds in afghanistan contributors to the volumealmost all military veterans of the afghan wargenerally agree that the american people are culturally unable to win wars like this one. About 17% of the cost of the american war effort then.
1147 1433 309 212 609 640 356 403 1249 1054 314 466 256 1500 324 953 990 1382 1418 639 484 413 719 1488 1545 826 1107 1323 587 1090 1022 357 249 862 177 1447 1533 1350 406 1431 1135 669 170 268 1204 613